What size heat pump do you need for a 2,000 sqft home?

Are you a homeowner who is thinking about getting rid of their furnace or central air conditioner – or both – and installing a heat pump instead?

If so, this is an increasingly popular choice, especially in moderate climates where homes have a balance of heating and cooling needs. For many homeowners, heating with a heat pump will be cheaper than with a natural gas furnace. Even if that’s not the case, having only a single piece of equipment to handle all of your heating and cooling can make a heat pump the most economical choice.

The cost of a heat pump comes down to several factors, including equipment choice, local pricing, building insulation, and climate. The last two factors affect the rate of heat loss and heat gain in a home, which will determine the size of the heat pump you need.

When talking about the size of a heat pump, we are really referring to its heating and cooling capacity. In North America, this is often measured in tons. One ton is equal to 12,000 British Thermal Units (BTUs) of heating or cooling per hour. This means that a 1 ton heat pump can provide 12,000 BTU/hr of heating or cooling, a 2 ton unit can do 24,000 BTU/hr, and so on.

Heat pump size is also influenced by the square footage of your living space. All other things being equal, the bigger your space, the greater your heating and cooling needs will be.

The average home in the United States is 1,818 square feet in size. This means that if your home is around 2,000 sqft, it’s roughly an average home in the US. So what size heat pump would you need?

As mentioned above, this comes down to several factors, including some that are specific to your home. This article will give you some general guidelines and things to discuss with your HVAC installer.

What the approximate size of a heat pump needed to heat or cool 2,000 sqft?

A common rule of thumb is that for every 500 square feet of living space that you need to heat or cool, you need one ton of HVAC capacity. This means that for a 2,000 sqft single family home, the correct heat pump will be approximately 4 tons or 48,000 BTUs in capacity.

However, homes with the same square footage can have wildly different heating and cooling requirements. My house is very close to the national average – about 1,800 sqft – and I have a 2.5 ton heat pump installed. This is less than what the rule-of-thumb would suggest, even though I live in cold Buffalo. Part of the reason is that I’ve done my best to insulate and air seal my home as well as possible, even though it’s a very old home that was built in 1910.

But the other reason is that I retained an existing gas furnace as backup heat for my heat pump. This means that the heat pump is the primary heating source on all but the coldest days of the year. When it does get too cold for my heat pump to run efficiently, the gas furnace turns on to supply heat. This means that I was able to install a heat pump that is smaller capacity than what my heating needs are on the coldest days of the year. This is why backup heat, also known as auxillary heat or “strip” heating if electric resistance heating is used, is often included in heat pump design, even when it’s less efficient than operating the heat pump. You can read my article on backup heat to learn more about these tradeoffs.

Does heat pump sizing refer to heating, cooling, or both?

Both. You can think of a heat pump as an air conditioner with an extra component called a reversing valve. This valve allows the heat pump to reverse the flow of refrigerant, allowing it to either extract heat from outdoors to operate in heating mode, or extract heat from indoors when you want air conditioning.

In either case, the capacity of the heat pump, stated in tons, refers to both heating and cooling at the standard design temperatures. What this means is that if you have a 2,000 sqft home and your HVAC installer has specified a 4 ton heat pump, the heating and cooling capacity will both be approximately 48,000 BTU/hr. It’s approximate because heat pumps are sized to the half-ton, which is equal to 6,000 BTUs. That means there will be some rounding error.

The other reason this number is approximate is because both the heating and cooling performance of a heat pump is influenced by the operating temperature. The industry standard is to specify the heating performance at an outdoor temperature of 47°F and an indoor temperature of 70°F, while cooling performance is measured at an outdoor temperature of 95°F and an indoor temperature of 80°F.

It’s important to establish these standard design temperatures because cooling performance drops as it gets warmer outside, and heating performance drops when it gets colder. Not all heat pumps have the same efficiency; less efficient models will perform worse under extreme temperatures. That’s why heat pumps come with specifications such as HSPF2 and SEER2 to help consumers understand the performance of the model they’re choosing. You can read my article on heat pump terminology to learn more.

Here’s an example of the performance characteristics of one heat pump that shows how the minimum and maximum performance of changes with temperature:

You can also read about cold climate heat pumps, which are designed to perform very well even in bitterly cold conditions.

Why bigger isn’t better when it comes to heat pumps (and air conditioners and furnaces too)

At this point, you might be wondering if it isn’t better to simply choose the largest heat pump possible to make sure that you never have to worry about having enough heating or cooling performance. While this will cost more, if price isn’t a major concern for you, it might be tempting to go this route.

It’s generally a bad idea to oversize your heating and cooling equipment. That’s true of heat pumps, but also air conditioners and furnaces too.

Whether in heating or cooling mode, a heat pump that is sized too large will run for short cycles. This means that the unit will turn on, quickly produce a lot of hot or cold air, and then turn off. Your home will then eventually return to its previous temperature, causing the heat pump to switch on again for another short cycle.

Short cycles are less efficient than continuous operation. In fact, advanced variable speed heat pumps are designed to reduce their output so that they can run at a lower speed for a longer cycles or even continuously.

This is especially beneficial during the cooling season because heat pumps and air conditioners make your home more comfortable not only because they produce cold air, but they act as dehumidifiers too. As the heat pump operates in cooling mode, humidity will condense out of the air and be removed down the drain line. Oversized heat pumps will produce a lot of cold air in a short amount of time, but that short operation might not be enough to reduce your indoor humidity to a comfortable level, resulting in clammy air. In the worst cases, this could encourage the growth of mold.

Finally, with a ducted system, an oversized heat pump will have a larger blower motor, which will be louder. This also results in higher air pressure, which requires larger ducts to accommodate. Both these things will increase the cost of a system.

Myth: long operating cycles that make your heat pump “work harder” are bad

The other reason to avoid oversizing a heat pump is that short cycles cause a heat pump to wear out more quickly than continuous operation. This is because when a motor is first turned on, it briefly experiences a large surge in electric current. This is known as inrush or startup current¹, and it causes more wear and tear than continuous operation.

It’s a common myth that it’s bad for a heat pump or air conditioner to “work hard” by running for long periods of time, but it’s actually the opposite that’s true. In fact, while standard heat pumps and air conditioners operate at a single speed, more advanced models are two-speed or variable speed.

Load calculations to correctly size a heat pump for a 2,000 sqft home

While the rule of thumb might suggest that a 4 ton heat pump is the correct size for a 2,000 sqft home, this doesn’t take into account all the factors that make one home’s heating and cooling needs different from another. To properly size a heat pump, you need to know the rate of heat loss and heat gain for your home.

This is accomplished with a Manual J load calculation² performed by a qualified contractor. A Manual J involves a detailed accounting of the entire building envelope – such as windows, walls, roof, and insulation levels – square footage, the local climate, appliances, and more. The result of this calculation is an estimate of the maximum heating and cooling needs of your home, based on your climate and building design.

Here’s a sample from a Manual J report:

A companion to the Manual J is the Manual S calculation, which takes the data from the Manual J and uses it to select the correct equipment that is matched to the building’s heating and cooling needs.

It’s important to note that not every HVAC contractor will perform these calculations! Many will choose to use the easier rule-of-thumb method, which saves them time but can end up costing you money due to improperly sized equipment.

Average electricity use for a 2,000 square foot home in the US

The federal Energy Information Administration conducts the Residential Energy Consumption Survey (RECS) every five years, which collects detailed information about the energy usage of homes in the United States. It includes information on the price and amount of energy used for heating and cooling by square footage of home. It has two “buckets” that straddle the 2,000 sqft number, so I’ve included both of them in the tables below.

Here is the heating energy usage for US homes in the 2,000 square foot range. The RECS publishes by the quantity of BTUs used for heating, so I’ve converted that into the equivalent amount of natural gas and electricity. Natural gas here is listed as CCFs, but some utility bills will show therms instead. (They’re roughly equal: 1 ccf = 1.037 therms.)

Here is the average energy used for air conditioning by 2,000 square foot homes in the US:

Average cost of heating and cooling for a 2,000 square foot home

The tables above show the average energy used by households for heating and cooling, but how much does it cost to heat and cool the average 2,000 square foot home? That’s included in the RECS survey as well, which tracks the actual dollars spent by household.

Note that the data only includes households that use each type of heating or cooling. In other words, households that don’t have air conditioning or use a particular fuel for heating aren’t included in the averages.

Factors that affect the cost of household heating and cooling

As you would expect, larger homes have bigger heating and cooling costs. If you explore the data further, you can see that there are many things that affect that average amount of energy that households use for heating and cooling.

Climate is biggest factor: homes in the Southwest spend almost 4 times as much energy on air conditioning than homes in New England. Here’s a summary based on RECS data:

• Large homes have higher expenses
• Older homes have higher expenses
• Higher income households have higher expenses
• Newer homes have lower expenses
• Renters have lower expenses than owner-occupied households
• Urban households spend more on heating than rural homes, but urban households spend more on air conditioning than rural households

How much will a heat pump for a 2,000 sqft home cost?

According to the website Modernize, a new heat pump can cost between $4,500 to $12,000 depending on the size of your home, energy efficiency ratings, brand name, and the type of heat pump you install.

I personally paid about $6,500 for mine (a central ducted 2.5 ton unit with my old gas furnace acting as backup), so this range seems reasonable. Be sure to get at least a couple quotes, and always ask that your HVAC company perform a load calculation instead of using a rule-of-thumb to estimate the size of the heat pump you need.

Don’t forget about heat pump rebates

The Inflation Reduction Act gives a 30% tax credit on a heat pump, which is worth up to $2,000. However, the IRA also provides funding for a Home Energy Rebate program that is aimed a lower- and moderate-income households. This program is administered by states so it’s not available everywhere yet. However, if it’s available to you, the rebate available is worth up to $8,000 for a heat pump installation. Best of all, it’s an upfront rebate rather than a tax credit. You can read more about the Home Energy Rebates in my article.

Bottom line: you need to work with a good HVAC company to find out the size of heat pump you need for your home

While the 1 ton per 500 sqft rule-of-thumb might indicate that a 2,000 sqft house would need a 4 ton heat pump, as you can see there are many reasons why that might result in a heat pump that is too big or small for your home. Many factors affect the size of the heat pump you need, such as climate, building characteristics, and HVAC design choices.

References